User wants to design their ideal sleep supplement with specific ingredients and is curious about what others would include. They feel current products are either underdosed or too complicated.
I’m curious what people here would actually want — not what brands are currently selling. If you had to build your own sleep supplement with only 3–4 ingredients max, what would you choose and why? For example, would you go with things like: Melatonin Magnesium glycinate L-theanine Glycine Valerian root extract GABA Apigenin Ashwagandha Something else entirely? A few specific questions: 1. Would you prioritize falling asleep faster, deeper sleep, fewer wakeups, next-day freshness, or anxiety reduction? 2. Would you include melatonin at all? If yes, what dose? 3. Do you prefer something you can feel working immediately, or something that builds over time? 4. What delivery format do you prefer — powder, capsules, gummies, liquid, sublingual? 5. What’s your biggest frustration with current sleep supplements? I’m genuinely interested in how people here think about this. Most products feel either underdosed, overcomplicated, or too sedating the next day. Curious to hear what your “ideal” formula looks like.